Draft Trade Calculator
Team A Gives
Team B Gives
What is a Draft Trade Calculator?
A draft trade calculator is an analytical tool used by NFL front offices, analysts, and fans to assess the fairness of trades involving draft picks. Each pick in the NFL Draft is assigned a point value based on its position. The calculator sums the values of the picks exchanged by each team to determine which team is getting more “value.” The most famous model, which this calculator is based on, was developed by former Dallas Cowboys coach Jimmy Johnson in the early 1990s and remains a benchmark for draft day trades. This tool helps make sense of complex trades that involve multiple picks across different rounds, providing a clear, quantitative comparison.
The Draft Trade Calculator Formula and Explanation
There isn’t a single mathematical formula, but rather a value chart that assigns points to each draft pick. The first overall pick holds the highest value (3,000 points), and the values decrease with each subsequent pick. The logic is that a trade is “fair” if the total points of the assets exchanged by both teams are roughly equal. For example, if Team A trades away a pick worth 1,000 points, they should expect to receive a combination of picks from Team B that also adds up to approximately 1,000 points. Our draft trade calculator uses this foundational principle.
| Variable (Pick #) | Meaning | Unit (Points) | Typical Range |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | First Overall Pick | 3000 | N/A |
| 16 (Mid 1st) | Middle of First Round | 1000 | ~700-1200 |
| 33 (Early 2nd) | Top of Second Round | 580 | ~400-580 |
| 100 (Late 3rd) | End of Third Round | 100 | ~90-140 |
Practical Examples
Example 1: Trading Up for a Quarterback
Imagine the Atlanta Falcons hold the #8 pick (1400 points) and want to trade up to #3 (2200 points) to select a franchise QB. The Arizona Cardinals hold the #3 pick.
- Team A (Falcons) Receives: Pick #3 (2200 points)
- Team B (Cardinals) Receives: Pick #8 (1400 points) + Pick #43 (470 points) + a future 1st round pick.
In this scenario, the Cardinals need to acquire assets that close the 800-point gap. Pick #8 and Pick #43 total 1870 points. This is still short, which is why a significant future pick is often required to complete such a blockbuster trade. A team moving up for a top prospect almost always has to overpay according to the chart.
Example 2: Trading Down to Acquire More Picks
A team like the Philadelphia Eagles at pick #22 (780 points) might believe the player they want will still be available later, or they may want to fill multiple roster holes. They trade with the Kansas City Chiefs, who want to move up from pick #30 (620 points).
- Team A (Chiefs) Receives: Pick #22 (780 points)
- Team B (Eagles) Receives: Pick #30 (620 points) + Pick #95 (120 points) + Pick #130 (42 points) = 782 points.
This is a classic example of a balanced trade where one team moves up for a specific target, and the other moves down to accumulate more draft capital. This is a very common use case for any draft trade calculator.
How to Use This Draft Trade Calculator
Using this calculator is simple and intuitive:
- Enter Team A’s Picks: In the “Team A Gives” section, enter the overall pick numbers that Team A is trading away.
- Enter Team B’s Picks: In the “Team B Gives” section, do the same for Team B.
- Analyze the Results: The calculator will instantly update. The primary result will declare the winner based on the point totals.
- Review Intermediate Values: You can see the total points for each team and the exact difference in value.
- Visualize the Trade: The bar chart provides a clear visual comparison of the trade values, helping you quickly see the balance of the deal.
Key Factors That Affect Draft Trade Value
While the draft trade calculator provides a quantitative baseline, several qualitative factors can influence a trade’s true value:
- Positional Scarcity: A draft rich in wide receivers might devalue mid-round WRs, while a draft thin on offensive tackles could inflate the price to trade up for one.
- Franchise Quarterbacks: The chart’s values often go out the window when a team is desperate for a franchise QB. Teams will significantly overpay to get their guy.
- Player-Specific Tiers: General managers often group players into tiers. If the last player in a top tier is available, a team might pay a premium to trade up and grab them before the talent level drops off.
- Roster Needs: A team with a solid roster might be more willing to package picks to get one elite player, while a rebuilding team will prefer to trade down and acquire more “dart throws.”
- Contract Value: Picks at the end of the first round are especially valuable because they come with a fifth-year option for the player’s contract, a key benefit not available for second-round picks.
- Compensatory Picks: The number and position of expected compensatory picks can influence a team’s willingness to part with their standard draft selections.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
A: No. While it’s the most famous, other models exist, like the Rich Hill model or the Fitzgerald-Spielberger model, which is based on the actual contract values of players selected at each draft slot. Many teams have their own proprietary charts. However, the Jimmy Johnson chart remains the public standard for a draft trade calculator.
A: A common rule of thumb is to value a future pick as a mid-round pick in that round. For example, a future first-round pick might be valued as the 16th overall pick (~1000 points). This is a heavy discount, reflecting the uncertainty and delay in realizing the asset’s value.
A: No, this calculator is specifically for the NFL Draft. Fantasy football draft values are entirely different and depend on league scoring, roster size, and player positions, not a fixed point chart. You would need a different calculator for fantasy trades.
A: In the context of the calculator, “winning” simply means acquiring more points. However, the real winner of a trade is only known years later. If a team “loses” a trade on paper but drafts a future Hall of Famer, they truly won the trade.
A: Competition. If multiple teams are vying for the same pick to draft the same player, it creates a bidding war. The team that wants the player most will have to exceed the baseline value from the chart to secure the pick.
A: Our calculator includes values for all 257 picks in a standard 7-round NFL draft. Any number entered higher than that will be assigned a value of 0.
A: Yes, teams often include active players in draft-day trades. This calculator does not support valuing players; their value is subjective and determined by contracts, age, and performance. This tool is only a draft trade calculator for picks.
A: The value curve is exponential. The perceived value of drafting an elite, blue-chip prospect in the top 5 or 10 picks is exponentially higher than drafting a solid starter in the late first round. The chart reflects this steep drop-off in talent expectation.
Related Tools and Internal Resources
If you found this draft trade calculator useful, you might also be interested in these other resources: